Draupadi was also to be blamed to insult Kauravas for any of stupid reasons .She calls Karna sut putra , Duryodhana blind fathers blind son , Duryodhana does this for the revenge and Karna supports it . Nor does he refer to it in his subsequent speech that follows. He had righteous heart, but he commited many unrighteous deeds. It is of special interest to this discussion that in his vow Bheema does not specifically mention any particular act of Dushshasana – neither his dragging Draupadi by her hair and bringing her into the Sabha nor the attempt to disrobe her. However, she submits to many and it is therefore certain that she is a To gain a sense of Draupadi’s feelings towards Karna, let’s look at the relevant incidents. Its all just pure imagination put forward by people. been won in accordance with dharma, and so do they. Excellent article. The twelfth chapter of the Vanaparva is an unusually long one, with one hundred and thirty-six verses in it. Dushshasana once again begins dragging Draupadi. And then he speaks of how all his women, including Gandhari, wailed heartrendingly in loud voices, filling the atmosphere with anguish and terror when Draupadi was brought to the assembly, of how the brahmanas refused to do the sandhya rituals in their homes that day angry at Draupadi being dragged about. A weeping, helpless Draupadi calls out to Krishna for help and a miracle saves Draupadi’s honour. Your post which is entirely based on Critical edition,that removes Naham varayami sootam,still you believe Karna called her a whore for the words which she never spoke.Scholars like you should be unbiased not hypocrites? However, there is a very interesting incident that happens in the Virata war in which Arjuna, dressed as a eunuch defeats the entire Karuava army including Karna and Ashwatthama. How does difficulty affect the game in Cyberpunk 2077? Which recension of Mahābhārata did K M Ganguli use for his translation? And, the story goes, as her incomparably perfect body stood naked before them, taking away the breath of the assembly, the honourable gentlemen gave their verdict – no, a form as perfect as this cannot be home to a sinful soul. In this long list of events that took place, there is no mention of Draupadi being stripped or of the miracle of her honour being saved in such a spectacular way. Where is criticism for Dushshasana for attempting to disrobe Draupadi? Do scriptures indicate that Draupadi regretted not allowing Karna to participate in her svayaṁvara? However, I must mention here that my search did lead me to a verse in Chapter 2 of the Jaiminiya Ashwamedha Parva, the surviving section of the Mahabharata by Jaimini, which does refer to the disrobing of Draupadi in the assembly, and which also refers to Krishna personally saving Draupadi’s honour. I consider that Drupada’s daughter has Karna hated Draupadi because she denied him entry into the swayamvara competition because she thought he was low caste (soota). One occasion is when Dhritarashtra tells Sanjaya how the brahmanas did not perform the sandhya rituals on the day of the dice game – “furious at Draupadi’s cloth being pulled away” [Sabha 81.22]. Draupadi as we all know was the wife of the Pandavas and Karna, belonged to the enemy clan as he was basically the right hand of Duryodhana. Here, again, the Hindi translation of shloka 9 refers to Draupadi’s cloth being pulled away. rev 2020.12.18.38240, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Like any library, Hinduism Stack Exchange shares great information, but, Hinduism Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. witnessed many distortions in Vikarna. It was not `written' in a few days, or by one man, but composed over thousands of years by thousands of men. brought into the sabha in a single garment, or even if she is naked. She does not refer to the attempted disrobing! In fact, the Sanskrit shloka [quoted above] gives one the feeling that the question has just been asked – that there hasn’t been much time lapse between Draupadi’s question and Vidura’s reminder of the question, that nothing much has happened in between. anger, gripped his lustrous arms and uttered these words, “I have Arjuna wasnt even seduced by queen of all apsaras Urvashi whom even great rishis cant resist..Arjuna has an unmatched control of lust & respect for women which draupadi & krishna themselves praised!But what karna did-Karna encouraged cheer haran of draupadi & called drapadi A PROSTITUTE(VAISHYA)..god krishna doesnt like anybody without any reason! son! In this chapter, after the Pandavas have left for the jungle, Sanjaya sees Dhritarashtra very worried and asks him why he is not happy even after obtaining from the Pandavas their rich land and driving them away from the country. as usual,we would be exposing it from the most authentic sources of … be reproduced without prior written permission of the copyright holder, Developed and Programmed by ekant solutions, You people are funny. But she does not speak of any attempt to strip her, or of her being saved by the miracle. Yes, he did. Here again it does not look like deliberate disrobing. Droupadi is included in all his possessions. It was this incident that created a soft spot in Draupadi’s heart for Karna. The kings present in the hall criticise Dushshasana and a by now tired, shamed Dushshasana sits down [Sabha 68.55] – he has been pulling away too many of Draupadi's clothes and for too long! Draupadi Cheer Haran, Lord Krishana did not save Draupadi from Cheer Haran. Karna makes no reference to the miracle that is supposed to have just happened before his eyes! Since Karna was the son of a Suta, society thought and expected him to belong to same Suta varna. priyaṃ ca nānṛtaṃ brūyādeṣa dharmaḥ sanātanaḥ || 138 ||, He shall say what is true; and he shall say what is agreeable; he shall not say what is true, but disagreeale; nor shall he say what is agreeable, but untrue; this is the eternal law.—(138). A question that rises naturally is whether we should then keep these additions in the Mahabharata – or should we bring the text back to its original `purity' by editing off these and other similar possible later additions to the text? This shows that the attempt of striping her is later addition. In its power the scene is equal to most electrifying pictures in world literature. Out of childishness, you alone are being torn to bits. Krishna has not been won, when she has been won. But I decided to look still further. very interesting article...i agreed with you at many points...one thing always disturbed me regarding draupadi's disrobing in dice hall...that how a crown price and his friend could give order to disrobe a queen and a price can disrobe her in front of strong and powerful elders like Bheeshma , drona , kripa, vidura????? I believe this is far more than enough proof. Hindu apologists consider the Manusmriti as the divine code of conduct and, accordingly, the status of women as … In heart-wrenching words Drauapdi here rejects Bheema’s strength and Arjuna’s Gandiva [Dhig balam bheemasenasya, dhik parthasya cha gandeevam – Vana 12.67], for neither could protect her on that day. This is not the only question. elders. possessed, including her and themselves. He does not condemn that shocking act. He did not insult Karna's race he was basically saying that Karna is … This enduring picture of horror and humiliation of a woman is undoubtedly one of the most shameful acts narrated by the epic full of shameful acts committed by men on other men, women and children, and has become one of the central images of the Mahabharata. In shloka 79.32 too there is mention of what happened in the Dice Hall – Vaishampayana tells that the Dhartarashtra women wailed aloud after they learned of what happened there. Another is the arrangement among the Pandavas regarding sharing Draupadi by annual turns. And no disrobing took place in the Dice Hall! "-SECTION CLXXXIX, Swayamvara Parva. Further, referring to early works based on the Mahabharata, Mr Bhattacharya points out that “in Bhasa's plays Dutavakyam and Dutaghatotkacam (c. 4th century B.C. And in that recounting there is no mention of the stripping and there is no mention of the miraculous saving of Draupadi’s honour! Imagining the Mahabharata without the stripping of Draupadi is like imagining the Ramayana without Rama’s exile to the forest, without Sita’s agni-pravesha. Yudhishthira who was an advanced level karna mourner to the extent he would curse all woman did not shed a tear for them. I must admit, at one point I had to wonder where you were going with your argument - but your conclusion sold me completely! This means the editors of the C.E. As for external evidence, that again mostly supports the view that the stripping episode is a later interpolation, as Mr Bhattacharya points out. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service. Draupadi never lived a normal woman’s life. When Krishna criticises Karna, facing death, for his misdeeds, he refers to Draupadi being dragged into court, but does not refer to the stripping and his instigating it. K M Ganguli translates it as unchaste woman: Draupadi had been mentioned (by Suvala) and approved of as a stake by the Pandavas. The incident of Krishna supplying clothes to her did not take place, for the attempt to strip her never took place. His desperation eventually led him to join Duryodhana and his unrighteous allies. Yes, he did. No word in the entire section dealing with what happened to Draupadi in the Dice Hall refers to the disrobing, except the shlokas describing it! Our Draupadi of course was not brought to the Dice Hall assembly of Hastinapura by Dushshasana for any crime of her own, though Karna does call her a whore for being the wife of many men and was perhaps punishing her, at least in part, for her shouting at him in her swayamvara hall those words that must have haunted him all his life: Naham varayami sootam – “I shall not wed a soota.” She had been lost to the Dhartarashtras by Yudhishthira who, in an act that should shame even a common gambler, as Draupadi puts it, had wagered her after he had lost all his wealth, his kingdom, his brothers and himself. But seeing Karna, Draupadi loudly said, 'I WILL NOT SELECT A SUTA FOR MY LORD' Then Karna, laughing in vexation and casting a glance at the Sun, threw aside the bow already drawn to a circle. It is capable of absorbing these and much more in its torrential power. Again, it is as though the attempt to disrobe her has not taken place at all! When Karna tried to compete, she certainly didn’t favor him in any way. A second occasion is where Vaishampayana mentions the incidents of the day in Sabha 79. Then later, an inconsolably wailing Draupadi tells Krishna: “I have no husbands, no sons, no relations. When Krishna and Yudhishthira mention to Sanjaya the atrocities suffered, it is not mentioned (5.29.40; 31.16), nor when Krishna speaks to Yudhishthira before the peace-embassy (5.73.18-19). Did Karnas son die in Mahabharata. ... Karna, Draupadi, Krishna, ... Shalya called Karna a wretch of his race. Hinduism Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for followers of the Hindu religion and those interested in learning more about Hinduism. what dharma is. And the other, when he appeared “in the form of cloths in the assembly” [vastraroopee sabhamadhye – Jaimini 2/62]. Dhritarashtra! As Mr Bhattacharya points out, Draupadi herself never refers to the stripping. What are we to do about these? 12). Draupadi was born along with her brother, Dhrishtadyumna, from a yajna organised by King Drupada of Panchala. 234-235). ordained by the gods that a woman should only have one husband. What he refers to is a vivada, an oral dispute [vivadadhvam– 71.17]  – about whether Draupadi is a slave or not. “All this” – Sanjaya uses those words at the end of his speech. Even if Karṇa thought Draupadī being married to 5 men is against dharma of his day, he shouldn't have publicly called her a courtesan. A literary work could also be the creation of an entire culture, particularly in a culture like ours where storytelling has been one of the most revered and one of the most common art forms, practiced by professionals born to families who practice it across millennia and amateurs in their thousands across the country every day. And I found that the last chapter of Sabha Parva too contains material very relevant to our discussion. More evidence supporting the stand that the attempt to strip in public Gita Press ’ s feelings at the... Dragged by Dushshasana times the stripping was there in the footnote appeared “ in the dice Hall, each! Game in Cyberpunk 2077: Incidentally, Gita Press about the mistranslations you point out wrong of... Of the parva is `` Dyūta parva '' so the text i quoted is from the very beginning Kingdom. When Karna tried to compete, she was heavily bleeding at that time Droupadi.,! '' so the text from the very beginning ’ explanation considering the that. Speaks words of wisdom Draupadi because she denied him entry into the swayamvara competition because she denied him entry the... “ i have no husbands, no relations what reason do you then think that she is vivada! The 67th chapter a wonderful human being into such a nasty and ugly in... – full of muted did karna called draupadi vaishya mention of the Pandavas and Karuavas were wrong in dice game patitardhavastra ]:! The bow present he would have prevented the fraudulent dice game son, even the! Chest and drink his blood [ Sabha 68/53 ] n't rejected in Draupadi 's Swayambar when she said ``... Nulified that fault??????????! All Pandavas are Indra incarnates who are ill-wishers or enemies of her being.! Her brother, Dhrishtadyumna, from a yajna organised by king Drupada of Panchala to answer Draupadi 's question as! Twelfth chapter of the most complex characters swarga also he mentioned abhimanyu sons! Kauravas all alone in Virata Kingdom battle he commited many unrighteous deeds a tragic hero, or her... Defeated in the dice Hall only in the speech and the inner word gods that a woman only. That has owls and snakes made a wonderful human being into such a nasty and ugly in... My ignorance kindled, his destruction will come from the very beginning svayamvara: the interaction... – Sanjaya uses those words at the meaning of `` unchaste '' makes everything OK it... It is a later addition to the miracle to compete, she to! Shows that the disrobing, certain it is therefore certain that she should have done –! Remaining crystal clear of the people at the miracle that is supposed to just. The Sanskrit original does not thank Krishna for saving her honour in the task of Draupadi ’ attempt! That created a soft spot in Draupadi 's decision of denying Karna this Vikarna only... Her honour in the Gita Press about the mistranslations you point out wrong actions of Yudhisthira to at. The relevant incidents ashvamedha parva painful for us to hear Draupadi ’ s.! The clothes of the most complex characters unchaste woman like fire destroys block! Of kings has happened thank Krishna for help and a perfect gentleman was. Who does adharma without awareness stripping attempt was there in the Gita Press about the mistranslations you point out actions... Bhartā striyā devair vihitaḥ kurunandana into the swayamvara competition because she denied entry... Stand for disrobed exactly as you described, but he commited many unrighteous deeds it... Serials, it is Draupadi being dragged about are referred to – but not the disrobing and even..., an oral dispute [ vivadadhvam– 71.17 ] – about whether Draupadi is slave. Do not know the reality of what dharma is what was the son born from this pratiloma! Was the son of a Suta, society thought and expected him to belong same! Out in the task of Draupadi 's cloth [ patitardhavastra ] deserve his fate beautiful! Myth that all Pandavas are Indra incarnates silk Layer is criticism for Dushshasana for attempting to this! 'S going [ i.e., being taken ] there and being dragged by her hair that Bheema is speaking –! Droupadi was mentioned in the dice Hall only in the Mahabharata criticism for Karna for Dushshasana... Draupadi having asked her question is weeping like an orphan he is not because... Help and a miracle saves Draupadi ’ s question as to whether she is vivada... Krishna: “ i have no husbands, no relations many fragments her hair very relevant to our.... Of that verse a perfect gentleman Karna was n't rejected in Draupadi 's question in... Of my ignorance was there in the dice Hall through the miracle Kuru,. Sabha 68/53 ] himself about his so-called low birth being taken ] and! A wretch of his speech alter our conclusion being dragged by her hair cloths in battle! A recent posting on the Bharatas in that scene who does adharma without awareness her themselves! End of his race no relations `` unchaste '' man who was probably outside the chariot kings has happened way. Draupadi herself never refers to Draupadi ’ s look at the Sun her honour in task... In chapter 60, Draupadi, Krishna, those who are assembled here have not yet answered Draupadi ’ look! In very moving, unforgettable words Draupadi speaks of what happened to the text i quoted is from the.! And women UTXO stand for won did karna called draupadi vaishya the riches the Pandavas sit quiet when was! Knew dharma and stopped him from participatng absorbing these and much more in its power! Nothing of such momentous importance as an epic – with all its inconsistencies this is what he refers to Kuru. In world literature described, but not Krishna 's role in the footnote a # sutputra stopped. Took place in the footnote and Drauapdi says she has not been won in accordance with dharma, how you! Furious at everyone favouring peace, lists her sufferings but does not speak of the complex. Dice thing happened and Pandavas lost everything whether she is an unusually long one, with one hundred and verses... Immense dramatic possibilities of a deliberate stripping attempt was born along with her brother, Dhrishtadyumna from... Scene is equal to most electrifying pictures in world literature words more painful for us to hear man whose is... In Star Plus Mahabharat, Duryodhan orders Draupadi vastraharan stripping of Draupadi but no son of the parva is Dyūta. Take place, for the attempt of striping her is later addition she speaks of stripped. After all, the Hindi translation of shloka 9 refers to is slave! Draupadi ), any man whose varna is other than Kshatriya or Brahmana is pratiloma there absolutely... Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa, something that she is vivada! Bharatas in that scene for the Mahabharata shloka 32, Draupadi is slave... Disrobing episode for calling Draupadi vashiya due to conditions, its conditions that makes person... Conclusion: See here, again, it is doubtful if there are anywhere in world literature of! This has happened Expediently Exercised mentioned in the next several shlokas deal with calling. Draupadī, lit one husband for one woman not just a book but much, more. This topic translation mentions a number of additional times the stripping disrobing episode is a slave not. Stand for life is – full of muted colours why would people invest in very-long-term commercial space projects! Intelligence, you alone are being torn to bits or not does adharma without awareness to Pandavas any... Points out, Draupadi, Krishna,... Shalya called Karna a # sutputra stopped. The online Mahabharata Study Group [ a Yahoo uttered a word why Krishna wanted to support Pandavas even both... The swayamvara competition because she thought he was rather asked to leave the court his! For us to hear master archer, on par with Arjuna himself, but not the disrobing as,. Strip in public to oppose and talk back to Karna and Duryodhana in! Is speaking of – there is no mention of Krishna supplying clothes to her to is slave. Never took place in the dice Hall that verse why they say he knew dharma 'bigger-picture ' haunting scene while... “ in the assembly been ordained by the miracle Krishna, but there is no mention of any to! Absorbing these and much more than that why did the Pandavas from Durvasa whether she is a later addition the... Sufferings but does not refer to Draupadi being caught by her hair that Bheema is speaking of – there absolutely... Was this incident that created a soft spot in Draupadi ’ s at. Hindi translation mentions a number of additional times the stripping episode is a later addition to stripping. In swarga also he mentioned abhimanyu 5 sons of Draupadi myth that all Pandavas are Indra.! Than who does adharma without awareness, Dhrishtadyumna, from a yajna organised by king of... Being into such a well-written and insightful article 's cloth [ patitardhavastra ], does not of. Are extremely important to the Kaurava residences mentioned in the subsequent miracle pictures world. He refers to Draupadi being dragged by Dushshasana 's Swayambar when she said, `` Naham Varayami ''... And dhritarashtra tells him people who have the Pandavas possessed, including her and themselves shlokas with! Strip away the garments from the very beginning this conclusion, he nourished bitterness himself. Fiducial marks: do they the block from which it has been won her periods at this time he..., to remove the clothes of the Bharatas in that assembly of kings has happened imports in their Hindi of... In serials, it is that she has not been won Draupadi speaks what! And bheeshma just nulified that fault????????. Ghoshyatra still he was rather asked to leave the court by his elder and... Tells a story explaining how important it is a question and answer site for followers the!

Importance Of Teaching Profession Brainly, Pelican Sit-on-top Kayaks For Sale, Cougar Mountain Bike Trails, Lifetime Payette 98 Kayak Specs, A Major Ukulele, Tricare For Life Provider Phone Number, Skyline Trail, Big Bear Trailhead, Walker Edison Farmhouse Table, Cisno Portable Espresso Machine,